Manuscript heading: R. Stockton
Richard Stockton mention as one of the outstanding members of the Natchez bar was the grandson of Richard Stockton (1730-1828) a signer of the Declaration of Independence. His great-grandfather was John Stockton(1701-1758) a wealthily landowner who donated land to bring the College of New Jersey, now Princeton University, from its original location in Newark to Princton.
The New Jersey native studied law taking top honors at Princeton, University. and emigrated to the southwestern town of Natchez, Mississippi to seek fame and fortune.
He was described as a brilliant but high-strung lawyer and was on the Mississippi Supreme Court before turning 31. He resigned from the court in 1825 after a dispute over where the high court had the power to declare a war unconstitutional. In the same year he became attorney general.
Two years later while vacationing at Stovall Springs near Columbia. Stockton had a disagreement with a New Orleans merchant a Mr. Payson during a formal dinner at the inn. Both men drew pistols, but a bystander defused the situation The disagreement continued, and they decided to meet in New Orleans to settle the matter with a duel. Stockton was hit in the head and killed by the shot of Mr. Payson. Stockton left a note in his pocket which stated that he felt his “own conduct had been rash and wrong from the beginning” and it was his intention upon surviving the first fire to acknowledge his error and make amends with Payson. The account was published in a New Orleans paper on February 4,
1827. In the article it described Payson as a Bostonian. By 1830 Payson had accidently drowned in the Mississippi River.
Mr. Stovall
Born: 1773 Granville County, NC Death: 1832 Cheraw, Marion County, MS Burial: Details unknown but in Marion Co., MS
Charles Stovall moved from NC early in the 19th century and built a famous hotel and resort Stovall Springs near Columbia, MS. It became the most famous health retreat in Mississippi during the early 1800‚Äôs. After the battle of New Orleans , Andrew Jackson sent some of his sick and injured met there to recover. The resort attracted influential planters, politicians, merchants from the region including New Orleans and Natchez. The hotel peaked in 1821 when the Inn served as the capital of Mississippi during the 5th legislative session. In this session LeFleur’s Bluff in the center of the state renamed Jackson was selected to become the site of the permeant state capital.
The springs were presented as medicinal mineral waters. Stovall actively marketed them in newspapers, touting their diuretic, tonic, and aperient properties, and offering accommodations starting as low as $1/day in an 1826 advertisement.
The demise of the Inn was brought on by two deadly duels that while took place elsewhere were started there among the guest. One was the Stockton-Payson duel . (see the bio of R. Stockton) The
second happened almost at the same time after an argument at the Inn was known as the Ross and Gibbs duel. One a planter and the other a Jefferson County attorney, fought a duel in 1826 near Grand Gulf, Mississippi, on the west bank of the river. Both parties selected muskets for their weapons, and at first fire, both men fell mortally wounded. One man died after only a few hours while the other lingered for months. Richard Stockton was even present at this duel in the capacity of a surgeon.
While the duels were fought at the Inn they tarnished its reputation. It also probably made people question the quality of the water. One source state the hotel closed immediately after the duels and never reopened. The ruins of the once famous resort were still standing in 1891 according to one writer at the time but soon all the buildings were gone.
For someone who created and operated such a famous resort not much is known about Charles Stovall.
Source: Trip Through The Piney Woods, PDF pp. 141–143.